Allianz

Trade
CONTACT US
Search
A person is typing calculator

Bank Guarantees, Surety Bonds & TCI: Choosing the Right B2B Protection 

Updated on 30 June 2025

In the realm of global trade and high-value projects, managing risk is critical. When expanding into new markets or dealing with unfamiliar partners, a simple contract is often not enough to inspire confidence. A Bank Guarantee (BG) has long served as a trusted financial instrument to protect parties from default. But is it always the best solution? 

Today’s evolving trade landscape demands a more sophisticated approach. While understanding BGs is essential, it's equally important to know the alternatives – particularly Surety Bonds and Trade Credit Insurance (TCI). This guide explores these key instruments, helping you choose the right solution to trade and operate with confidence. 

 

Summary

Key Takeaways

  • Bank Guarantees (BGs): A bank's promise to pay on behalf of a debtor. They offer strong security but often require significant collateral, impacting the applicant's working capital and credit lines. 
  • Surety Bonds: A three-party agreement where an insurer (Surety) guarantees the performance or obligations of one party to another. They are often a more capital-efficient alternative to BGs, especially for performance-related risks in construction and service contracts. 
  • Trade Credit Insurance (TCI): Protects a seller's entire portfolio of accounts receivable against the risk of non-payment, ideal for businesses engaged in ongoing trade seeking broad protection. 
  • Strategic Choice is Key: The best tool depends entirely on the specific risk you need to mitigate – project performance, a one-off payment, or ongoing trade receivables. 

What is a Bank Guarantee (BG)? 

A Bank Guarantee is a promise issued by a bank to cover a debtor's financial or performance obligations if the debtor fails to fulfill their contractual commitments. This mechanism shifts a specific risk from the beneficiary (the party receiving the guarantee) to the bank, creating a financial safety net for high-stakes transactions. 

BGs are commonly employed in industries such as construction, infrastructure, and manufacturing, often serving as a launchpad for companies venturing into new markets. 

The US Context: Standby Letters of Credit (SBLCs) In the United States, the functional equivalent of a bank guarantee is typically a Standby Letter of Credit (SBLC). Issued by a bank, it also serves as a guarantee of payment or performance and is triggered if the applicant fails to fulfill their obligation. 

Common Types & Uses of Bank Guarantees 

Bank Guarantees are versatile and used to cover specific obligations. The most common functional types include: 

  • Performance Guarantees: Assure a project owner (the beneficiary) that a contractor will complete the project according to the contractual terms. 
  • Advance Payment Guarantees (APGs): Protect a buyer who has made an upfront payment to a seller, ensuring the buyer can reclaim the deposit if the seller fails to deliver the goods or services. 
  • Bid Guarantees (Tender Bonds): Provide assurance to a project owner that a winning bidder will enter into the contract and provide any required performance guarantees. 
  • Warranty Guarantees: Ensure that a contractor will rectify any defects that appear during a specified warranty period after project completion. 
  • Financial Guarantees: Assure a seller that they will be paid by the buyer. 

The Pros and Cons of Bank Guarantees 

While valuable, BGs have significant challenges: 

Advantages: 

  • High Level of Trust: As a bank-issued instrument, they are widely accepted and trusted globally. 
  • Enables Transactions: They provide the security needed to facilitate large, one-off deals with new partners. 

Limitations and Considerations: 

  • Impact on Capital: Banks often require 100% collateral, meaning the applicant must tie up a significant amount of cash or assets. This directly impacts working capital and liquidity. 
  • Reduces Credit Lines: A bank guarantee usually utilizes a company's available line of credit, reducing its capacity for other borrowing needs. 
  • Cost and Complexity: The application process can be time-intensive and expensive, involving various bank fees. 
  • Drafting Risks: A poorly drafted guarantee can have loopholes, leading to disputes or non-enforceability. 
  • Limited Coverage: BGs typically cover specific financial or performance breaches, not broader issues like political risk or commercial disputes. 

Key Alternatives: Surety Bonds and Trade Credit Insurance 

Given the limitations of BGs, businesses should explore powerful alternatives that are often more efficient and strategic. 

Surety Bonds: The Specialist Alternative 

A Surety Bond is a three-party agreement: 

  • Principal: The party obligated to perform (e.g., a contractor). 
  • Obligee: The party who receives the guarantee (e.g., a project owner). 
  • Surety: An insurance company (like Allianz Trade) that guarantees to the Obligee that the Principal will perform its obligations. 

Bank Guarantee vs. Surety Bond: While they often cover the same needs (Performance, Bid, Advance Payment), Surety Bonds offer crucial advantages: 

  • Capital Efficiency: Surety Bonds do not require 100% collateral. They are underwritten based on the Principal's financial strength and track record, freeing up cash and bank credit lines for operational use. 
  • Specialist Expertise: Sureties possess deep industry knowledge (especially in construction and services) and conduct their own rigorous underwriting, which can provide an additional layer of project vetting. 
  • Claims Handling: Sureties typically investigate claims to validate them, protecting the Principal from unfair or premature calls on the guarantee. 

For performance-related obligations, a Surety Bond is often a more strategic and financially sound choice than a Bank Guarantee. 

Trade Credit Insurance (TCI): Portfolio Payment Protection 

TCI operates differently. Instead of securing a single transaction or performance obligation, Trade Credit Insurance protects a company's entire portfolio of accounts receivable from the risk of non-payment due to customer bankruptcy or protracted default. It is the ideal tool for businesses engaged in ongoing trade with multiple customers on open account terms. 

How to Choose: Bank Guarantee vs. Surety Bond vs. TCI 

Swipe to view more

Use Case Best Fit: Bank Guarantee Best Fit: Surety Bond Best Fit: Trade Credit Insurance
Securing project completion Usable, but ties up capital. Ideal. Capital-efficient, specialist underwriting. Not applicable.
Securing an advance payment Usable, but costly. Ideal. Protects the payment without freezing capital. Not applicable.
Securing payment for a single, high-value shipment Good Fit. A classic use case, especially an SBLC. Not applicable. Can be used, but TCI's strength is portfolio coverage.
Protecting ongoing sales to multiple buyers Impractical and extremely expensive. Not applicable. Ideal. Comprehensive, scalable, and cost-effective.

Allianz Trade: Your Partner in Secure Commerce 

Navigating these options requires expertise. At Allianz Trade, we specialize in providing a comprehensive suite of risk management solutions. Our experts can help you: 

  • Understand whether a BG, Surety Bond, or TCI is the right fit for your specific business needs. 
  • Access market-leading Surety and TCI products tailored to your industry. 
  • Leverage our global insights to trade and operate securely, both domestically and internationally. 

Conclusion

Bank Guarantees are a trusted instrument for mitigating risk, but they are not a one-size-fits-all solution. By understanding the distinct advantages of Surety Bonds for performance obligations and Trade Credit Insurance for payment risks, businesses can adopt a more strategic, capital-efficient, and comprehensive approach to risk management. Allianz Trade is committed to providing the clarity and solutions you need to ensure every transaction is a confident step forward. 

Need help determining the best risk mitigation strategy for your business? Contact an Allianz Trade expert today. 

You can also be interested in...

Definition-of-gearing-ratio
Definition-of-gearing-ratio

Gearing ratio: definition, types & calculation method

Gearing ratio is one way to measure a company’s financial health. It involves comparing the company's capital to the amount of money the company has borrowed.

More information
Trade Creditors
Trade Creditors

Trade Creditors

Understanding Trade Creditors: Essential Insights for Business Success

If you’re running a business, there are many aspects of bookkeeping and accounting that you’ll learn over time. One term you might encounter is ‘trade creditor’. But what does it mean, and how will trade creditors impact your business?

More information
SME Financing
SME Financing

SME Financing

Unlocking Business Growth: A Guide to SME Financing and Loans in Hong Kong

In Hong Kong, there are various SME financing and loan options available to support business growth, including large personal loans, collateral-free SME loans from banks, and government-subsidized schemes.

More information

SMEs: Why you should invest in solid credit management

Taking the time to draw up a solid credit management strategy can help set SMEs up for profitable growth.

More information
Image: People discussing on a coach

Our expertise and commitment

Allianz Trade is the global leader in  trade credit insurance and  credit management, offering tailored solutions to mitigate the risks associated with bad debt, thereby ensuring the financial stability of businesses. Our products and services help companies with risk management,  cash flow management, accounts receivables protection, Surety bonds, business fraud Insurance, debt collection processes and  e-commerce credit insurance ensuring the financial resilience for our client’s businesses. Our expertise in risk mitigation and finance positions us as trusted advisors, enabling businesses aspiring for global success to expand into international markets with confidence.

Our business is built on supporting relationships between people and organizations, relationships that extend across frontiers of all kinds - geographical, financial, industrial, and more. We are constantly aware that our work has an impact on the communities we serve and that we have a duty to help and support others. At Allianz Trade, we are strongly committed to fairness for all without discrimination, among our own people and in our many relationships with those outside our business.